Opposing Perspectives of Evidence-Based and Precision Medicine

December 1, 2016 Mike Pallagi, Senior Content Manager

Debra Madden, a clinical-applications systems analyst for Associated Neurologists, interviewed geneticist and pathologist Gabriel Bien-Willner, MD, PhD, FCAP, in an 8,000-word piece for The American Journal of Managed Care titled, “Do We Need to Realign Evidence-Based Versus Precision Medicine?” 

Throughout the piece, Bien-Willner expressed a number of provocative views on:

  • The ineffectiveness of evidence-based medicine: Madden quoted a recent statement Bien-Willner made as an audience member at the annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology: “I would argue that evidence-based medicine is incompatible with precision medicine and, as currently practiced, is not effective for cancer care.”
  • The challenges of oncologists actually understanding genetic data: Bien-Willner believes that technology has a critical role to play in the effort to “simplify the workflow and knowledge gaps,” and said that any expectations for oncologists to have an expert understanding of genomics are misplaced and a threat to the success of healthcare’s ongoing precision-medicine journey.
  • The relationship between evidence-based medicine and precision medicine: Bien-Willner contends that “these are 2 opposing perspectives and methods for deciding what proper care is.” He argued that while the former relies on “empirical statistical inference,” the latter relies on “logic and our understanding of the mechanisms that underlie disease,” and he reiterated the lack of compatibility between today’s approach to evidence-based medicine and precision medicine.

Read the full interview here.


Learn about the genomics-health IT gap for precision medicine: read the Chilmark report now! 

The Value of Semantic Interoperability to Healthcare
The Value of Semantic Interoperability to Healthcare

The unambiguous exchange and reuse of clinical knowledge

Migrating to the Cloud for the Health Industry
Migrating to the Cloud for the Health Industry

How can healthcare information be made available where and when it is needed?


Subscribe to our Blog!

First Name
Last Name
Thank you!
Error - something went wrong!